Share, , Google Plus, Pinterest,

#MCM Showdown: Which Scott Did it Better?

Today’s #MCM showdown is brought to you by the lovely Scott brothers from Tree Hill, Lucas and Nathan Scott. For nine seasons (eight for Lucas, I’m still bitter about it) audiences got to enjoy the drama and romance that followed the Scott family. Today we get to settle it, which Scott did it better?

First off, let’s just get this one out of the way, both Scott boys were amazing *coughattractive basketball players.

Lucas: 1
Nathan: 1
Everyone loves an athlete with a sensitive side. Cue Lucas Scott, basketball player and brooding writer.

Lucas: 2
Nathan: 1
Nathan gives us faith in love and actually has one of the best most stable and consistent relationships on the show. #NaleyForever

Lucas: 2
Nathan: 2
Speaking of love, Lucas had his moments. It’s no boom box being held up outside of a window, but it might as well be. Anyone remember his red door moment?

Lucas: 3
Nathan: 2
Then again, Lucas wasn’t always the king of romance…Peyton or Brooke? Brooke or Anna? Brooke or Peyton (again)? Peyton or Lindsey? For God’s sake, pick one man!

Lucas: 3
Nathan: 3
Nathan’s determination to stop at nothing to support Haley’s career, even if that meant paying Chris Keller to keep his mouth shut and help her.

Lucas: 3
Nathan: 4
Season three was filled with tragedy but the moment Lucas left Brooke to run back in for Peyton, we knew they were meant to be together.

Lucas: 4
Nathan: 5
But we can’t forget that Nathan ran back in for Haley too.

Lucas: 4
Nathan: 6
From what we’ve gathered it looks like it’s the baby Scott that’s won our hearts so what about yours? Tell us which Scott wins your heart and tweet us @TalkNerdyWithUs and tell us why!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *